KEENE, N.H. (MyKeeneNow) Vinyl enthusiasts tuning in to WKBK Radio this week got a treat as the ever-popular Mighty John the Record Guy—also known as John Marshall—joined host Dan Mitchell for the second hour of Good Morning with Dan Mitchell on Wednesday morning. Known nationally for his encyclopedic knowledge of collectible vinyl, Mighty John returned to share insights on records that could be worth hundreds—or even thousands—of dollars, right from your attic or basement.

A regular guest on Mitchell’s show and the man behind MoneyMusic.com, Mighty John spotlighted several standout records for May, starting with the Dave Clark Five’s “Feeling Glad All Over” album. Depending on the cover photo, this LP ranges in value from $30 (with instruments) to $125 (without instruments). As he explained, tiny differences in artwork or sound can mean big bucks.

Other high-dollar discs included two Ike and Tina Turner albums—“Don’t Play Me Cheap” and “It’s Going to Work Out Fine”—both potentially worth up to $400. Their value, Mighty John noted, stems from their initial lack of commercial success, making surviving copies rare today.

A Supertramp picture disc version of “Breakfast in America”, featuring an image of a waitress on the vinyl itself, came in at $500. Even more jaw-dropping was a rare pressing by The Byrds covering Bob Dylan’s “The Times They Are a-Changin’”—complete with picture sleeve—valued at a whopping $2,500.

Throughout the segment, Mighty John emphasized that “little things make a huge difference” when it comes to record value. An Elvis Presley 45 of “It’s Now or Never” with a piano intro, for example, can fetch $300, compared to $40 without it.

Beyond price tags, Mighty John also shared personal anecdotes—including being referenced in several Stephen King novels, such as “Christine” and “Hearts in Atlantis.”

He wrapped up the segment by promoting a current sale on his website, where collectors can find appraisal guides listing over one million vinyl records, as well as bonus resources like guides to picture sleeves and a directory of record buyers.

Listen to the full interview: